DePauw Tigers
+
Skyler Hoefener

2027 Prospect Fit Report — DePauw University

Coaching Staff Brief Prospect–Program Fit Report Time-Sensitive — Spring 2026

Skyler Hoefener

2027 CDM / Center Back — St. Louis, MO · AFA Fillies ECNL · Villa Duchesne High School

5'11"
Height
4.1
GPA
33
ACT
300+
Iron Man
CDM / CB
Positions
ECNL
Club Level

01

Overall DePauw Fit Assessment

91Fit Score

Excellent fit. DePauw's elite academics, NCAC championship program, and close-knit campus align strongly with this prospect. Only ~191 miles from home.

Mutual Interest (25%)
80 / 100
Positional Need (20%)
88 / 100
Physical Profile (15%)
95 / 100
Academic Alignment (15%)
92 / 100
Playing Style / System (10%)
88 / 100
Intangibles / Culture (15%)
95 / 100
02

Roster Gap Analysis — Defensive Unit

Fall 2027 defender projections based on the 2025-26 roster via depauwtigers.com.

Critical Context: NCAC Championship Program on the Rise

DePauw went 12-5-3 (4-1-2 NCAC), winning the NCAC Tournament Championship and earning an NCAA DIII Tournament bid. Jayla Logan earned NCAC Midfielder of the Year. On a 23-25 player DIII roster, the attrition below is program-defining — the 2027 recruiting class will essentially build the entire back line.

Defender Attrition — 8 of 9 depart (88.9%)
8 departing · 1 returning
# Name Pos Ht Year (25-26) Hometown Fall 2027 Status
4 Sophia Grueninger D 5'10" Sr. Indianapolis, IN / North Central Graduated Spring 2026
6 Sadie Gibson D 5'1" Sr. Clarksville, TN Graduated Spring 2026
15 Liv Ehlers D 5'6" Sr. Grayslake, IL Graduated Spring 2026
19 Macy Happe D 5'7" Sr. Evansville, IN Graduated Spring 2026
14 Peyton Howard D 5'6" Jr. Portland, OR Graduated Spring 2027
17 Molly Heller D 5'6" Jr. St. Louis, MO / Nerinx Hall Graduated Spring 2027
27 Ashley Green D 5'2" Jr. Elkview, WV Graduated Spring 2027
29 Eva Lynch D 5'9" Jr. Burlington, WI Graduated Spring 2027
9 Kate Robinson D 5'4" Fr. Highland, IN Returning — Junior
Height Advantage — The Numbers Speak

The only returning defender (Kate Robinson) stands 5'4". Skyler Hoefener at 5'11" would be 7 inches taller than the lone returning back. At DIII, where rosters skew shorter, that height differential transforms how opponents approach set pieces and the defensive third entirely.

St. Louis Recruiting Pipeline

Molly Heller (#17) hails from St. Louis, MO (Nerinx Hall) — confirming DePauw already recruits from the STL metro and Catholic school network. Skyler's background at Villa Duchesne fits squarely within this established pipeline.

Midfield Attrition Compounds the Problem

NCAC Midfielder of the Year Jayla Logan departs alongside Macy Miller and Elle Lewis. In total, 10 of 16 midfielders will be gone by Fall 2027 — leaving massive gaps across both the back line and central midfield. A CDM/CB like Hoefener addresses both positions simultaneously on a 23-25 player DIII roster.

DIII Roster Dynamics — Why This Attrition Is Program-Defining

DIII rosters run 23-25 players — every spot carries outsized weight. Losing 8 of 9 defenders and 10 of 16 midfielders is not normal turnover; it is a near-total defensive rebuild. The 2027 recruiting class will not supplement the back line — it will be the back line. CDM/CB versatility is not a bonus at this level; it is a roster construction necessity, effectively filling two positions.

Key Takeaway for Staff

At 5'11" with CDM/CB versatility, Hoefener brings rare height for the DIII level and addresses the two most critical positional needs simultaneously. With 8 of 9 defenders gone and the NCAC Midfielder of the Year departing, the 2027 class needs immediate contributors who can anchor the defense from day one. Hoefener's 16-assist season from CDM shows she does not sacrifice offense to defend — she does both.

Competitive Recruiting Landscape

A 5'11" ECNL captain with a 4.1 GPA, All-Region honors, and 16 assists from CDM does not go unnoticed. Programs at every level are evaluating her. ECNL pedigree is premium at DIII — most programs rarely land this combination of physical tools, production, and academics. The programs that engage first will have a decisive advantage.


03

Player Evaluation

Scouting assessment based on film review, statistical analysis, and competitive context.

ECNL KC 2025 — Game Highlights
Scouting Narrative

Physical Profile: At 5'11", Hoefener would likely be the tallest defensive player on DePauw's roster — a genuine rarity at the DIII level where rosters skew shorter. She thrives in physical battles and wins aerial duels through height, strength, and timing. The 300+ game Iron Man streak signals elite durability for an NCAC program competing for championships.

Defending 1v1: A lockdown defender who consistently neutralizes top attackers. Missouri All-Region and All-Conference First Team as a sophomore — in a state with strong high school soccer — validate her quality against top opposition. ECNL pedigree brings tactical sophistication that translates immediately to the collegiate game.

Distribution: 16 assists in a single season from the CDM position — leading her entire conference in assists from the deepest-lying midfield role. Most defensive midfielders at any level register 3-4 assists; she quadrupled that while still fulfilling her primary defensive responsibilities. With Jayla Logan setting the standard for midfield excellence at DePauw, a CDM who creates from deep would give Coach Allen a midfield opponents cannot cope with.

Engine / Fitness: Cross Country All-Conference and a 3rd-place finish in the Greater St. Louis 10k confirm elite aerobic capacity. The NCAC's compressed travel schedule to Denison, Kenyon, Oberlin, and Wooster demands sustained fitness — Hoefener can maintain high intensity deep into matches and across November tournament runs.

Leadership / Culture: ECNL captain. Founded Villa Duchesne's FCA chapter, serves as Duchesne House Leader, Student Council representative, 100+ service hours. She didn't join a club — she built one. On a campus of 1,917 students where leadership is expected, her initiative and community-building instincts align precisely with DePauw's mission.

Academic Fit: Her 4.1 GPA exceeds DePauw's 3.92 average enrolled GPA, and her ACT of 33 sits above DePauw’s middle 50% ACT range of 25–30. NHS member with 5 Honors and 1 AP through sophomore year. Zero admissions friction — she would be admitted on academics alone, making her one of the cleanest recruits from an admissions perspective.

04

Bidirectional Fit Analysis

The case from each side — and why timing matters.

Why DePauw Makes Sense for Her
Elite liberal arts education: Top 50-60 nationally. Small classes, mentorship-driven teaching, and rigorous curriculum — the right environment for a 4.1 GPA student.
Only ~191 miles from home (~3 hour drive): Closer than many programs she is evaluating. Family can attend every home match.
NCAC Tournament Champions — program is peaking: Championship and NCAA Tournament bid at exactly the moment she would arrive. Timing could not be better.
Small campus, close-knit community: 1,917 undergraduates mirrors the Villa Duchesne environment — known, supported, and challenged on and off the field.
Strong merit-based financial aid: 98% of students receive aid, averaging $42,882. Committed to making education accessible through merit and need-based packages.
70%+ study abroad rate: Among the highest per capita in the country — a differentiator most programs cannot match.
Produces more CEOs per capita than almost any school its size: Alumni network and career outcomes punch far above its weight.
45 minutes from Indianapolis: College-town focus with easy access to a major city for internships and culture.
Why She Makes Sense for DePauw
5'11" brings rare height for DIII: Physically dominant in aerial duels, set pieces, and defensive confrontations — a dimension extremely difficult to recruit at this level.
CDM/CB versatility on a smaller roster: Fills roles in both defensive midfield and the back line, giving Coach Allen maximum tactical flexibility. Effectively two roster spots in one.
16 assists from deep — a creative engine: Program-changing offensive production from CDM. She doesn't just defend — she creates. That combination is almost unheard of in DIII.
4.1 GPA matches DePauw's academic profile: Exceeds DePauw's 3.92 average enrolled GPA. Zero admissions friction — a recruit that admissions welcomes.
Leadership profile fits liberal arts values: FCA founder, Duchesne House Leader, 100+ service hours. At a school that develops leaders, she arrives having already demonstrated exactly that.
ECNL pedigree is premium at DIII: Most DIII programs do not land ECNL-level talent. Her competition level and tactical sophistication would provide immediate on-field impact and elevate the training environment.
Multi-sport athlete: XC All-Conference and 10k results confirm elite fitness. The 300+ game Iron Man streak means she shows up — every match, every session.
Why Timing Matters

Skyler is a junior with ECNL showcases throughout spring 2026 and Playoffs in June — every event is an opportunity for competing staffs at every level to engage her. DePauw's championship momentum makes this the ideal moment to recruit. First-mover advantage on high-academic prospects of this caliber is real and measurable.


05

Credential Summary

Verified athletic and academic honors.

Athletic
Missouri All-Region Team (Sophomore, 2025)
All-Conference First Team (Sophomore, 2025)
Led Conference in Assists — 16 (2025)
STL Best XI First Team (2025)
Cross Country All-Conference (Junior, 2025)
Cross Country All-Sportsmanship Award (Junior, 2025)
Greater St. Louis 10k — 3rd Place Female 19 & Under (2025)
ECNL Team Captain (2024–present)
All-Conference Honorable Mention (Freshman, 2024)
Started All 20 Games as Freshman (2024)
Record-Breaking Start — Six Goals Allowed in 8-0 Start (2024)
Iron Man Streak — 300+ Games Without Missing
Mid-Buchanan Invitational All-Tournament Team (2025)
Academic
4.1 GPA (unweighted)
National Honor Society Member
5× Villa Duchesne Honor Roll
Founder & President, Fellowship of Christian Athletes
History & Theology Department Awards
Mother Eugene Aude Award
Rebecca Award
Duchesne House Leader
5 Honors & 1 AP Through Sophomore Year
100+ Hours of Community Service
Student Council Representative
ACT: 33 (above DePauw’s middle 50% ACT range of 25–30)
06

Opportunities for Engagement

Suggested next steps to build on this mutual fit.

Why This Matters

A 5'11" ECNL CDM/CB with a 4.1 GPA, All-Region credentials, 16 assists, and leadership values aligned with DePauw's mission — only 3 hours from campus. Admissions-clean, academics exceed DePauw's averages, and merit aid makes the financial case compelling. At DIII, this combination of tools, production, and character is exceptionally rare.

01
A personal note goes a long way. A brief message from Coach Allen referencing something specific — the championship season, NCAC strength, or academic environment — would distinguish DePauw from the generic outreach she receives from programs at every level.
02
A campus visit could be the tipping point. She's only 3 hours away. A spring visit aligned with a training session lets her see the facilities, meet the team, and experience DePauw firsthand. Greencastle and the campus tend to sell themselves in person.
03
Merit aid conversations signal serious interest. DePauw can't offer athletic scholarships, but with 98% of students receiving aid (avg. $42,882), even an early discussion about merit possibilities helps the family see DePauw is invested in making it work.
04
The championship pitch is your best tool right now. NCAC Tournament Champions, NCAA Tournament — a program on the rise under Coach Allen. For a competitive athlete, the chance to join at the moment of ascent is irresistible. Use the momentum.
05
Live evaluation at ECNL Playoffs. Highlights are embedded above and on her YouTube channel. For a live look, ECNL Playoffs in June offer top competition. Staff presence at a match signals genuine interest.
06
The DePauw experience is the differentiator. Small classes, 70%+ study abroad, a school that produces more CEOs per capita than almost any its size. For a Villa Duchesne student-athlete, DePauw mirrors what she already values — at a higher level.
Recruiting Window Advisory

A prospect of this caliber — 5'11", ECNL captain, All-Region, 16-assist season, 4.1 GPA — is being recruited at every level. DePauw's championship trajectory is its strongest argument. Every week without engagement is a week another staff fills the gap. Programs that move first on high-character, high-academic prospects win them. The goal: get her on campus before end of spring 2026, when juniors finalize their lists.

← Back to Full Profile